top of page
Search

Hiring a Property Manager vs. Self-Managing: Pros and Cons

When it comes to owning rental property, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is whether to hire a property manager or handle the management yourself. Each approach comes with unique advantages and trade-offs, and the right choice often depends on your investment goals, portfolio size, and lifestyle.



Hiring a Property Manager


Pros

  1. Hands-Off Management A property manager handles tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, and even evictions. This saves you time and stress, especially if you own multiple properties or live far from your rentals.

  2. Professional Tenant Screening Experienced managers have established systems for background checks, income verification, and rental history. This often results in higher-quality tenants who pay on time and stay longer.

  3. Legal and Regulatory Expertise Landlord-tenant laws can be complex and vary by state. Property managers are trained to stay compliant with fair housing, eviction processes, and local ordinances, reducing your legal risk.

  4. Maintenance Network Most managers have a trusted network of contractors and vendors, often at better rates than an individual owner could secure. This means faster, more cost-effective repairs.

  5. Scalability If your goal is to grow your portfolio, a property manager frees you to focus on acquisitions and strategy rather than day-to-day operations.


Cons

  1. Cost Property managers typically charge 8–12% of monthly rent, plus leasing or setup fees. This cuts into your cash flow, particularly on smaller properties.

  2. Less Direct Control You won’t have a say in every decision. Some owners struggle with not being involved in tenant selection, repairs, or management style.

  3. Quality Varies Not all property managers are created equal. Hiring the wrong one can lead to poor communication, tenant dissatisfaction, and increased vacancies.



Self-Managing (DIY)


Pros

  1. Maximized Cash Flow By avoiding management fees, you keep more of your rental income — a big advantage if your margins are already tight.

  2. Direct Control You make all the decisions, from tenant approval to maintenance priorities. Some landlords prefer the personal touch and believe it leads to better outcomes.

  3. Closer Tenant Relationships Managing yourself often means stronger relationships with tenants, which can translate into longer stays and fewer disputes.

  4. Hands-On Learning New investors gain valuable experience by managing properties directly. This knowledge makes you a sharper investor, even if you later outsource.

Cons

  1. Time-Consuming Answering tenant calls, scheduling repairs, handling complaints, and collecting rent can easily become a second job.

  2. Emotional Stress Dealing with late payments, disputes, or evictions can be draining — especially if you’re not comfortable with confrontation.

  3. Knowledge Gaps Without professional expertise, you risk mishandling legal notices, violating fair housing rules, or making costly mistakes.

  4. Limited Scalability Self-managing is feasible for one or two properties. But as your portfolio grows, managing everything yourself often becomes overwhelming.



Bottom Line

  • Hire a Property Manager if… you value time freedom, own multiple properties, or invest out of state.

  • Self-Manage if… you want to maximize cash flow, enjoy being hands-on, or are just starting out and want to learn the ropes.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your goals: Do you want to own a job, or do you want to own an investment?



Reach out to Bill or Bob to learn more about becoming an investor with KB4 →



 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page